Payroll fraud might seem like something that only happens at large companies—but small businesses are often the most vulnerable. With fewer internal controls and limited oversight, a trusted employee can exploit the system without detection for months or even years.
FREE Download – Payroll Fraud Checklist
What Is Payroll Fraud?
Payroll fraud occurs when someone manipulates a company’s payroll system for personal gain. It can take many forms, including:
- Creating fake employees and collecting their paychecks (ghost employees)
- Inflating hours worked or hourly rates
- Misclassifying employees as independent contractors
- Continuing to issue paychecks after someone has left the company
A Cautionary Tale: A Small Business in Trouble
Consider “Maple & Co.,” a boutique ecommerce company with ten employees. The owner, focused on customer growth, trusted a long-time office manager with payroll duties. Over 18 months, the manager created a ghost employee under a fake name and had direct deposits sent to their personal bank account.
The fraud cost the company over $80,000. Beyond the financial loss, the incident shook employee morale, damaged the company’s credibility, and led to a costly investigation and legal fees. It took months to rebuild trust and implement new safeguards.
Common Types of Payroll Fraud
- Ghost employees: Nonexistent workers on the payroll
- Timesheet fraud: Employees exaggerate hours or work unauthorized overtime
- Pay rate manipulation: A payroll admin changes rates without approval
- Commission padding: Inflating sales numbers to earn higher commissions
Warning Signs of Payroll Fraud
Be alert to these red flags:
- Unexplained increases in payroll expenses
- Employees receiving paychecks after termination
- Payroll records that are inconsistent or incomplete
- Multiple employees using the same bank account
- Resistance to outside audits or software updates
- Sudden increases in overtime hours
How to Prevent Payroll Fraud in Your Business
Preventing payroll fraud doesn’t have to be overwhelming. Start with these steps:
- Separate Duties: Never have one person responsible for hiring, payroll, and timesheets. Assign tasks to different employees or outsource payroll to a reputable provider.
- Review Reports Regularly: Set time each month to review payroll summaries, employee lists, and direct deposit reports. Cross-reference hours and rates with employee agreements.
- Conduct Surprise Audits: Occasional, unannounced payroll audits can reveal inconsistencies before they escalate.
- Use Payroll Software with Audit Trails: Modern payroll tools can detect duplicate entries, irregular hours, and unauthorized changes.
- Terminate Access Immediately: When an employee leaves, revoke their system access right away—especially if they handled financial tasks.
- Educate Your Team: Let employees know that payroll fraud is taken seriously and will be prosecuted. Transparency helps build accountability.
- Separate Duties: Never have one person responsible for hiring, payroll, and timesheets. Assign tasks to different employees or outsource payroll to a reputable provider.
- Managerial Approval Required: Always require a manager’s sign-off before approving overtime hours or making changes to an employee’s pay rate. This helps ensure transparency and prevents unauthorized adjustments.
Need support tightening your payroll systems?
Protect your business and your employees. Don’t wait until fraud happens to act.
We help business owners like you protect what you’ve built. Let’s make your back office more secure so you can focus on growing your business. Schedule a consult today.